BotsfolioBotsfolio
Tools

Can a Trading Bot Withdraw Your Money? API Keys and Custody

Jay Sharma
Jay Sharma · Founder, Botsfolio
Published
In short

A trading bot that connects to your own exchange account through a trade-only key or sign-in can place and cancel orders. It can't send your money anywhere, because withdrawals stay switched off. Two risks remain. A leaked key can still place bad trades, which is why the key should also be locked to the bot's IP address. The exchange holds the money too, so its own security matters: Binance lost about $6.3 billion from its hot wallets on October 29, 2026 and said it would bear the loss. The setup to avoid is any platform that takes your deposit and trades it for you. Botsfolio trades on your own exchange account through Coinbase sign-in or an API key with withdrawals off.

Every trading bot asks for the same thing: access to your money. What that access allows is the whole question. A bot that can only trade is a very different risk from one that holds your deposit. Both differ again from the risk that the exchange itself gets hacked.

This page sorts the setups by who holds the money. It shows what a trade-only key can and can't do. Then it goes through the cases that taught each lesson, from FTX in 2022 to the Binance hack and the SignalPlus key revocation this autumn. We make Botsfolio, so weigh that. Every outside fact is linked.

The short answer

No, not if the connection can't withdraw. A trading bot needs to read your balance and place and cancel orders. It never needs to move money off the exchange. On the major exchanges you can create an API key with trading on and withdrawals off. Coinbase also lets an app connect through its own sign-in, limited to what the app asks for.

With that kind of connection the bot can buy and sell inside your account. Your money leaves only when you withdraw it yourself. That stops theft by withdrawal. It doesn't stop every risk, which is what the rest of this page is about.

Who holds your money

Three ways a trading bot can reach your money
From the products' own pages and the cases linked below.
SetupWho holds the moneyWhat the bot can doExamples
The bot connects to your exchange accountYou, in your own account at the exchangePlace and cancel orders. With withdrawals off it can't move money out.3Commas, Bitsgap, Coinrule, Botsfolio
The bot is built into an exchangeThe exchange, which also runs the botTrade your balance on that exchangePionex
A platform takes your deposit and trades it for youThe platformWhatever it wants. You get money back only if it lets you.The shape regulators keep warning about
Licensed fund managers also hold client money, under regulation. That is a different product from a trading bot.

In the first setup the bot company never touches your money. 3Commas, for one, says it cannot withdraw your funds. In the second the money and the bot sit with one company, as with Pionex, so that company's security matters twice.

The third is the one to walk away from. On November 3, 2026 the Alberta Securities Commission warned about scams that claim "a proprietary AI system or trading bot can predict markets". The deposit is the point of those schemes. Our guide to whether AI trading bots are legit lists their red flags.

What a trade-only key can and can't do

A key with trading on and withdrawals off
The keyCan it?Why it matters
Read your balances and ordersYesThe bot needs them to size its orders.
Place and cancel ordersYesThat is the trading.
Withdraw to an outside addressNoThe money leaves only when you take it out.
Work from another computerOnly without an IP lockA key locked to the bot's server address fails anywhere else.

A trade-only key is not harmless if it leaks. In 2022, attackers who obtained API keys from the bot platform 3Commas used them to place trades that pumped thin coins. Value moved out through the market instead of through withdrawals. That is the reason for the second setting, an IP restriction. A key locked to the bot's server address doesn't work from anyone else's machine, even if it is copied.

The exact settings for Coinbase, Kraken, Binance, Binance.US and Bybit are in our guide to connecting an exchange safely.

What has gone wrong and what each case shows

Five cases, five lessons
Dated from the sources listed at the end of this page.
WhenWhat happenedWhat it shows
November 2022FTX: on November 9 its website said it was not processing withdrawals. On November 11 FTX and more than 100 affiliated companies filed for bankruptcy.Money held by an exchange or a platform is only as safe as that company.
20223Commas: customer API keys leaked and were used to place trades. The company confirmed the leak on December 28, 2022.Withdrawals off stops theft by withdrawal, not abuse by trading. Lock keys to an IP address.
September 29, 2026The SEC charged two groups that drew investors in through WhatsApp and other platforms with talk of AI trading. In one case, the SEC said, "there were no AI trading bots".A bot that needs your deposit is the warning sign.
October 29, 2026Binance: about $6.3 billion was taken from its hot wallets. Withdrawals stopped, then reopened in phases from November 1. A spokesperson said "Binance will bear the financial impact of the stolen funds".In every setup an exchange holds the money. Its security and its record on losses matter.
November 5, 2026SignalPlus, a trading platform that connects to exchanges, was breached after an engineer accepted a fake Microsoft Teams invitation. Binance removed every API key linked to SignalPlus as a precaution. Deribit revoked its keys too. SignalPlus put its losses below $82,000.A bot company's own security matters. Exchanges can cut off its keys in one move. One key per service limits the damage.

None of this makes exchanges or bots unusable. It shows which setting protects you from what. Withdrawals off protects the money from a leaked key. The IP lock protects the trading. Neither protects you from the exchange itself, which is why the exchange you pick matters as much as the bot. Which ones serve your country is in which exchanges an AI can trade on.

Giving an AI assistant access

AI assistants can trade too. Through a connector called Coinrule MCP, ChatGPT, Claude or Grok can build and launch strategies on a Coinrule account by chat. The rules don't change because the one placing orders is an AI:

  • Give it trading access only. Never withdrawals.
  • Lock the key to an IP address where the service allows it.
  • Use one named key per service, so you can revoke one without breaking the rest.
  • Don't paste keys into a chat window. Chat history keeps what you type.

How Botsfolio connects

Botsfolio is the first setup in the table. You pick the cryptos and the amount. Botsfolio AI does the research and testing and trades them on your own exchange account. Botsfolio never holds your money.

What Botsfolio does at connect
  • Coinbase: you sign in on Coinbase's own site. The access covers balances and orders. It can never send funds.
  • Binance, Kraken and Bybit: the key is checked. Botsfolio refuses a key that can withdraw.
  • Binance.US: you confirm withdrawals are off. Binance.US doesn't let us check that setting, so we ask you to.
  • IP lock. If a key works from any address, you see a warning with the address to add. Bybit requires one.
  • Stored encrypted. Keys and sign-in tokens are encrypted before they are saved.
  • Disconnect any time. Botsfolio cancels its open orders on the exchange first, then removes the key and stops the portfolios there.

What happens to your orders and coins when you stop is in stop and disconnect. Every filled trade, paper and real money, also goes into a public log sealed every hour. How to check any bot's record, ours included, is in how to verify an AI crypto trading bot's track record. Here are the results as of the last daily close:

Results, and how each is measured

Real money
As of the Nov 17, 2026 close, real-money portfolios running on Botsfolio are down 5.13% since Oct 22, 2026, from real fills after all fees. Holding the same cryptos over the same days is down 24.82%. See real-money results
Paper trading live markets
As of the Nov 17, 2026 close, Botsfolio AI's own portfolios, trading live markets with paper money since Oct 8, 2026, are down 6.63% together after trading costs. Holding the same cryptos over the same days is down 26.47%. Real users' paper portfolios, run by the AI on cryptos they picked, are down 5.91%, while holding those cryptos is down 24.13%. Each trade happens as the market moves, not on past prices. No real money. See paper trading results
Backtest
The same rules from every monthly start since 2018, on past prices, next to holding the same cryptos. See the backtest

New trades are sealed every hour in a public log, signed by Botsfolio and anchored in Bitcoin. How to verify

Past results don't predict future ones.

Before you connect any bot

Six questions to answer first
  • Where will my money sit? In your own exchange account, at the exchange that runs the bot or with the bot company.
  • Does the connection ask for withdrawal permission? If it does, stop there.
  • Can I lock the key to an IP address? A copied key then works nowhere else.
  • Can I see every trade the bot places? On the exchange and on a public record.
  • Can I disconnect without asking anyone? Deleting the key on the exchange should end access at once.
  • What happens to open orders when I stop? Orders left on the exchange keep working until someone cancels them.

FAQ

Not if the connection can't withdraw. A trading bot only needs to read balances and place and cancel orders. Create the API key with withdrawals off, or use a trading-only sign-in such as Coinbase's. The bot can then trade inside your account but can't send money out of it.

Sources

Every page below was read on November 18, 2026. Pages change, so check the link before you rely on a line. If something here is wrong or out of date, tell us in the chat and it will be corrected.

  1. BleepingComputer: Crypto platform 3Commas admits hackers stole API keys. Leaked keys used to place trades
  2. Cointelegraph, December 28, 2022. 3Commas confirms the leak
  3. Wikipedia: Bankruptcy of FTX. Withdrawals stopped on November 9, 2022, bankruptcy on November 11
  4. SEC press release 2026-95, September 29, 2026. Charges against two groups that used WhatsApp and other platforms
  5. Alberta Securities Commission, November 3, 2026. Investor alert on AI trading scams
  6. Wikipedia: 2026 Binance hack. Date of the hack
  7. CoinDesk, November 1, 2026. Hot wallets, phased withdrawals, who bears the loss
  8. CryptoSlate, November 6, 2026. Binance and Deribit cut SignalPlus keys, how it was breached
  9. crypto.news, November 5, 2026. SignalPlus losses below $82,000
  10. Coinrule MCP. Connecting ChatGPT, Claude or Grok to a Coinrule account

Watch Botsfolio AI trade live

Botsfolio AI paper trades on the live market, and every entry, stop and exit is public.

How to read these numbers: the buy and hold comparison, biggest drop, and how the portfolios are tested.

See everything Botsfolio AI trades live

Paper trading on real prices. Not investment advice.

Botsfolio is software. It is not investment advice and it is not tailored to you. Exchange settings and the cases above are as reported on November 18, 2026. Paper trading results are simulated. Trading crypto can lose money. Past performance does not predict future results.